Skin in the Game: Understanding Earnest Money Like a Pro

INTRO

Earnest money is a good-faith payment made by buyers at the beginning of a real estate transaction to demonstrate their intention to close on the property.
 
You might hear it referred to as EMD, short for Earnest Money Deposit. An EMD POP (Proof of Payment) is evidence that the buyer has made that payment - whether it’s a screenshot of a secure portal transaction, a photo of a check delivered to the title company, or another valid form of proof. An EMD Receipt, meanwhile, is issued by the entity holding the funds to confirm they’ve been received.
While I’ve certainly seen contracts without an earnest money amount (especially in VA loan cases), it’s not common. That good-faith payment shows the buyer has some skin in the game, and it gives everyone confidence that the deal is moving forward in earnest.

How Much Earnest Money Should You Pay?

This is real estate - there’s no single rule. Here in Northeast Ohio, I most often see an amount around 1% of the purchase price, or roughly $1,000 for homes under $100,000. But there’s no standard; I’ve seen deposits anywhere from $500 to several thousand dollars.
 
A variety of factors influence the amount a buyer offers, and the number is always the buyer’s decision - though most will lean on their agent’s advice.

When advising my clients, I generally start around the 1% mark, then adjust based on how competitive the property appears to be. If multiple offers are likely, a higher amount can strengthen the offer. Conversely, if a buyer is using down-payment assistance or has limited liquid funds, I may suggest a smaller deposit.

The EMD amount should be viewed in the context of the entire offer. The best offer is one that’s both accepted and beneficial to all parties - and sometimes, that little extra earnest money makes a meaningful difference.

When Is EMD Paid?

It’s paid according to the date specified in the contract. Each brokerage sets its own guidelines: some require a check to accompany the Offer to Purchase, while others allow a Promissory Note stating the buyer’s intent to pay within a defined period.

Typically, the deadline for payment falls between one and seven days after the offer is accepted - often leaning toward the sooner side. The reason is simple: the earnest money serves as proof that the buyer genuinely intends to close.

Sometimes, however, the contract allows for payment after another event - for example, when a buyer can’t view the property until there’s an accepted offer, or when the seller needs to complete certain work first.
What matters most is that the EMD is paid exactly as the contract states.

Who Holds the Earnest Money?

That depends on brokerage policy. Because earnest money is tightly regulated, many brokerages prefer that the title company hold the funds in escrow - especially since the buyer’s remaining closing funds will eventually go to the same account.

Some brokerages, though, choose to hold the deposit themselves. Occasionally, I’ve even seen non-refundable deposits held by sellers, separate escrow agencies, or other entities. It ultimately depends on what’s outlined in the purchase agreement.

How Are EMD Payments Made in Greater Cleveland?

It varies, but the process is straightforward: buyers can usually pay by check or ACH transfer through the title company’s secure portal. Payments of $10,000 or more must legally be wired.
 
If your brokerage holds earnest money directly, you’ll likely write the check to them.

If you’re paying by check, take a quick photo before mailing or dropping it off - and send it to your agent so there’s a record. The same goes for ACH payments; always save your proof of payment. It’s a small habit that can prevent major headaches.

What Happens If We Fall Out of Contract?

It happens. Despite everyone’s best intentions, sometimes buyers and sellers can’t move forward under the original terms. What happens to the earnest money depends entirely on why and when the deal falls apart.
 
Contingencies are built into most contracts to protect buyers - and, by extension, their deposits. For instance, inspection contingencies allow a buyer to walk away (and typically receive their EMD back) if significant defects are found. What qualifies as “significant,” of course, can be open to interpretation - which is one reason I always recommend a professional inspection.
Financing contingencies offer similar protection: if a buyer can’t secure a loan, they’re generally entitled to their deposit back.
 
It’s crucial to understand your purchase agreement and its contingency clauses. Just as important: know when the buyer is not entitled to a refund. For example, if a buyer simply changes their mind and wants a different house, that’s considered a breach - and the seller will likely retain the EMD.

When both parties agree on where the money should go, they sign a Mutual Release (MR), which acts as escrow instructions. If they don’t agree, the funds can’t be legally released for at least two years without a court order. After that period, the buyer may recover the funds - though there may still be procedural steps to complete.

In short, this area can get messy. While I’m happy to discuss hypotheticals, any real disputes over earnest money should go through legal counsel.

Can I Avoid Paying Earnest Money?

It’s possible, but rare. I’ve seen contracts without EMD - most often in VA loans or between parties who already know each other - but sellers generally prefer to see a good-faith deposit.

In competitive markets, a strong EMD can even make your offer stand out. A small or absent deposit, on the other hand, might weaken your position. Still, if all parties agree, the EMD can be waived.

What Happens If I Don’t Pay My EMD?

Please, pay your earnest money as agreed. Not paying it doesn’t mean you don’t owe it if the deal collapses.

If you’re nervous about the property condition or your financing, raise those concerns before the offer is written. Your agent can build conditions into the contract, such as delaying payment until after inspection or until specific funds clear.

Skipping the payment altogether can have consequences. In some cases, your agent could even be held liable for that amount. So yes, pay your EMD, and if you foresee a timing issue, talk to your agent early.

As always, if you have questions about earnest money - or any other part of the buying process - I’m happy to help.

More Listings
More Listings
Midcentury Living Room Corner in Greater Cleveland

WORK WITH ME

Partner with my expert team to turn your real estate goals into reality. Enjoy personalized service and dedicated guidance throughout every step for exceptional results.